FIFO vs LIFO: What Kroger's $2.55B Reserve Reveals
November 19, 202614 min read

FIFO vs LIFO: What Kroger's $2.55B Reserve Reveals

Kroger reported a $2.55B LIFO reserve in fiscal 2025. Learn how inventory accounting changes margins, asset values and tax timing without changing sales.

M

MOATEY Team

MOATEY Research

Two retailers can sell similar products at similar prices yet report different gross margins and inventory values because they use different accounting methods. The physical products may be almost identical. The accounting assumptions used to determine their costs are not.

Kroger provides a particularly useful example. At January 31, 2026, the supermarket operator reported approximately $9.45 billion of inventory before its last-in, first-out adjustment. It then deducted a $2.55 billion LIFO reserve, leaving approximately $6.89 billion of inventory on its balance sheet.

During fiscal 2025, Kroger also recorded a $157 million LIFO charge, compared with $95 million in the previous fiscal year. The difference was largely connected to higher product cost inflation.

These figures illustrate why inventory accounting deserves attention in fundamental analysis. The method used to assign inventory costs can influence reported profitability, balance-sheet values and tax timing without changing the products customers actually purchased.

What is the difference between FIFO and LIFO?

FIFO stands for first-in, first-out. Under this method, a company assumes that the oldest inventory costs are assigned to goods sold first. The inventory remaining on the balance sheet therefore generally reflects more recent purchase costs.

LIFO stands for last-in, first-out. Under this method, the most recent inventory costs are assigned to goods sold first, leaving older costs in the accounting value of the remaining inventory.

The distinction concerns how costs are assigned to inventory and the cost of goods sold. It does not necessarily describe how products physically move through a warehouse or store.

A supermarket might physically sell older products before newer ones to reduce spoilage, while still using LIFO for financial reporting.

This distinction is important because investors should not confuse accounting cost-flow assumptions with actual inventory management.

The company still purchases goods, places them on shelves and sells them to customers. FIFO and LIFO determine which historical costs are assigned to those sales in the financial statements.

A simple example of how FIFO and LIFO change profit

Imagine a retailer purchases ten identical products for $10 each. Later, the purchase cost rises, and the retailer buys another ten for $12 each.

The retailer now has twenty products with a combined purchase cost of $220.

During the period, it sells ten products for $20 each, generating $200 in revenue.

Under FIFO, the retailer assigns the original $10 purchase cost to the ten units sold. Cost of goods sold is therefore $100, and gross profit is $100.

Under LIFO, the retailer assigns the more recent $12 purchase cost to the ten units sold. Cost of goods sold becomes $120, and gross profit falls to $80.

Revenue is identical under both methods. The company sold the same number of products at the same price and purchased the same inventory.

The difference comes entirely from which costs are assigned to the products sold.

The balance sheet changes as well.

  • FIFO: $100 cost of goods sold, $100 gross profit and $120 ending inventory.
  • LIFO: $120 cost of goods sold, $80 gross profit and $100 ending inventory.

In this simplified example, FIFO produces $20 more gross profit and a $20 higher ending inventory balance.

That does not mean the FIFO company is economically more efficient. Nor does it mean the LIFO company sold its products at a lower price.

The accounting methods simply assign different purchase costs to the same economic activity.

Why inflation makes the distinction important

During periods of rising purchase prices, newer inventory generally costs more than older inventory.

LIFO assigns those higher recent costs to cost of goods sold, which typically reduces reported gross profit relative to FIFO, assuming other factors remain equal.

FIFO instead assigns older costs to sales, leaving more recently purchased and potentially more expensive products on the balance sheet.

This can produce higher reported earnings during inflationary periods because the cost recognized against current revenue reflects earlier, lower prices.

Neither method changes the amount paid to suppliers or the price charged to customers.

But the income statement can look different.

That distinction matters when comparing two companies. A retailer using LIFO may report a lower gross margin than a similar retailer using FIFO, partly because it recognizes more recent purchase costs.

At the same time, the LIFO method can produce an older and potentially less representative inventory balance.

The relationship can reverse when purchase costs decline. Newer costs may then be lower, potentially producing lower cost of goods sold under LIFO than FIFO.

Investors should therefore understand the direction of cost inflation before interpreting changes in reported margins.

Kroger's $2.55 billion LIFO reserve

Kroger's fiscal 2025 Form 10-K provides a clear real-world example of the difference.

At January 31, 2026, the company disclosed:

  • Inventory before LIFO adjustment: $9.445 billion.
  • LIFO reserve: $2.553 billion.
  • Inventory reported after the adjustment: $6.892 billion.

The relationship is straightforward:

$9.445 billion - $2.553 billion = $6.892 billion.

Kroger also reported that approximately 91% of its fiscal 2025 inventory was valued using LIFO. The remaining inventory, including substantially all fuel inventory, was primarily valued using FIFO.

The $2.55 billion reserve therefore reflects a substantial difference between Kroger's inventory values before and after its LIFO adjustment.

It does not represent $2.55 billion of cash held somewhere outside the balance sheet. Nor is it necessarily an amount that would immediately become profit if the company sold its inventory.

It is an accounting difference associated with the historical costs assigned to inventory.

In Kroger's case, the company explicitly states that replacement cost exceeded the reported inventory carrying amount by the disclosed reserve.

That makes the reserve useful when investors compare Kroger's inventory accounting with businesses that use different cost assumptions.

Why the LIFO reserve differs from the annual LIFO charge

The LIFO reserve and LIFO charge are related, but they are not interchangeable.

The reserve is a balance-sheet measure. It reflects the accumulated difference between inventory values under the relevant accounting approaches at a particular reporting date.

The LIFO charge is an income-statement measure. It describes the period's effect on reported costs and profits from the LIFO adjustment.

At the end of fiscal 2024, Kroger reported a LIFO reserve of approximately $2.404 billion.

At the end of fiscal 2025, the reserve had increased to approximately $2.553 billion.

That represents an increase of $149 million.

Meanwhile, the company reported a $157 million LIFO charge during fiscal 2025.

Those two numbers are close, but not identical. Changes in inventory composition, balances and other accounting adjustments can affect the relationship between the reported reserve and the period's LIFO expense.

The distinction is useful because investors should not assume that every movement in the reserve must equal the income-statement charge without examining the company's reconciliation and accounting policies.

The annual charge is particularly relevant to understanding profitability. The reserve provides additional information about the cumulative effect on reported inventory values.

How Kroger's LIFO charge affected operating profit

Kroger reported approximately $1.89 billion in operating profit for fiscal 2025.

Its LIFO charge was $157 million.

The company also reports a measure called FIFO operating profit, which excludes the LIFO charge. On that basis, fiscal 2025 operating profit was approximately $2.05 billion.

The reconciliation is:

$1.890 billion reported operating profit + $0.157 billion LIFO charge = $2.047 billion FIFO operating profit.

This provides a clearer perspective on the effect of the inventory accounting method.

However, FIFO operating profit is a company-defined non-GAAP measure. It should not automatically be interpreted as the profit the company would have reported under an entirely different accounting system.

Investors also need to recognize that other factors had a much larger influence on Kroger's fiscal 2025 earnings.

The company recorded approximately $2.5 billion in fulfillment network impairment and related charges during the year.

That was considerably larger than the LIFO charge.

The lesson is not that inventory accounting explains all of Kroger's profitability changes. It is that the LIFO adjustment represents one identifiable component of the difference between the company's reported and management-adjusted results.

A careful investor should understand each adjustment rather than simply treating every addition to reported earnings as equivalent.

What Kroger's latest 2026 results show

The importance of the accounting method is also visible in Kroger's latest available quarterly filing.

During its fiscal second quarter ended August 15, 2026, Kroger reported a $39 million LIFO charge, compared with $62 million in the corresponding quarter of 2025.

For the first two quarters of fiscal 2026 combined, the charge was $91 million, compared with $102 million during the corresponding prior-year period.

Management attributed the lower year-to-date LIFO charge to lower expected annualized product cost inflation.

The company's August 2026 Form 10-Q also reports second-quarter operating profit of approximately $971 million and FIFO operating profit of $1.01 billion.

The $39 million difference reflects the LIFO charge for the quarter.

This helps illustrate why investors should monitor the charge over time rather than simply applying a fixed adjustment to every reporting period.

When the rate of cost inflation changes, the accounting effect can change as well.

But the direction of that accounting effect does not necessarily tell investors whether Kroger is gaining market share, improving sourcing efficiency or strengthening its competitive position.

Those questions require additional operating evidence.

Does LIFO change cash flow?

FIFO and LIFO do not change the actual amounts paid to suppliers for a particular set of inventory purchases.

The retailer still needs to finance inventory purchases and receives cash when customers pay for the products.

However, inventory accounting can influence taxable income where the applicable tax rules permit the relevant method.

During periods of rising purchase costs, LIFO often produces higher cost of goods sold and lower taxable income than FIFO, assuming the method is permitted and applied for tax purposes.

That can reduce current cash tax payments.

This creates a genuine cash-flow consequence even though the inventory accounting choice does not itself change the physical purchase or sale of goods.

The timing matters.

Lower current tax payments can allow a business to retain more cash for investment or other uses. But the benefit should not automatically be regarded as permanent.

If inventory levels decline and older, lower-cost LIFO layers flow through cost of goods sold, previously deferred income can become taxable.

This is one reason investors should distinguish a temporary tax benefit from a permanent improvement in operating economics.

The accounting treatment may affect the timing of cash taxes without changing the company's underlying ability to sell products profitably.

The risk of LIFO liquidation

LIFO liquidation occurs when a company reduces inventory levels enough that older inventory cost layers are included in cost of goods sold.

When historical purchase costs were substantially lower than current costs, those older layers can reduce reported cost of goods sold and increase reported profit.

Consider a retailer that has accumulated inventory layers during years of rising prices.

If it normally maintains stable inventory levels, recent purchase costs may continue flowing through the income statement under LIFO.

But if the retailer significantly reduces its inventory, older cost layers may be released.

Those layers can carry costs substantially below current replacement prices.

The resulting increase in reported gross profit does not necessarily reflect better pricing, stronger supplier relationships or improved operations.

It can partly reflect the accounting effect of using older inventory costs.

For investors, this creates a potential earnings-quality issue.

A period of unusually high gross profit might look like operational improvement, even though some of the benefit arises from drawing down historical inventory layers.

That does not mean every inventory decline produces a material LIFO liquidation. The actual outcome depends on the company's inventory pools, cost history and accounting method.

Investors should review inventory disclosures for evidence of liquidation effects rather than assume that declining inventory always creates an earnings benefit.

Comparing companies that use different inventory methods

The distinction becomes particularly relevant when comparing US companies with international businesses.

LIFO is permitted under US GAAP but is not permitted under IFRS inventory accounting standards. IFRS generally uses methods such as FIFO or weighted average cost for interchangeable inventories.

The IFRS Foundation's inventory guidance explains the economic differences between those cost-flow approaches.

This can complicate comparisons between retailers using different accounting frameworks.

Suppose two businesses have similar product costs, sales volumes and inventory turnover.

One uses LIFO under US GAAP while the other uses FIFO under IFRS.

During a period of rising purchase prices, the FIFO business might report a higher gross margin and a higher inventory carrying value even when the underlying operations are economically similar.

Investors can improve comparability by examining the LIFO reserve and the period's LIFO charge where the necessary disclosures are available.

For a LIFO company, adding the reserve back to its inventory carrying amount can provide a useful bridge toward the disclosed pre-LIFO inventory value.

Similarly, adjusting reported operating profit for the period's LIFO charge can help isolate the accounting effect from other operating changes.

But these adjustments should not be mistaken for a complete economic restatement.

Different companies may also have different product mixes, shrinkage, supplier arrangements, inventory turnover, distribution costs and definitions of gross profit.

Accounting consistency is necessary for a fair comparison, but it is not sufficient by itself.

Inventory accounting does not establish a competitive advantage

One important distinction concerns the relationship between inventory accounting and actual business quality.

A retailer might report a strong FIFO gross margin because it has favorable supplier terms, efficient distribution, low inventory losses or attractive customer pricing.

Those could be meaningful operating characteristics.

However, the accounting method used to determine cost of goods sold is not itself evidence of a durable competitive advantage.

A company does not become economically stronger simply by choosing a method that reports a higher accounting profit.

Nor does a company automatically become less competitive because LIFO assigns higher recent costs to its sales.

Investors need to distinguish between how the economics are measured and what creates those economics in the first place.

For a supermarket chain, factors such as purchasing scale, distribution efficiency, customer loyalty, store productivity and pricing competition can influence long-term returns.

FIFO and LIFO affect how some of those results appear in the financial statements, but they do not determine whether the underlying business possesses a lasting advantage.

What MOATEY currently sees in Kroger

As of November 19, 2026, MOATEY rates Kroger Poor, with an overall assessment of 21.9 out of 95.

The framework currently awards 21.9 of 65 available Fundamentals points and 0 of 30 Valuation points.

Within the fundamental assessment, Kroger receives 7.8 of 15 Financial Health points, 1.2 of 15 Growth points, 11.9 of 15 Management points and 1 of 20 Moat points.

The current five-year growth measures include revenue growth of 1.69%, earnings growth of 3.0% and free-cash-flow growth of -18.98%. The earnings and free-cash-flow measures include adjustments made within MOATEY's framework and should not automatically be treated as identical to unadjusted company-reported growth figures.

These observations provide a broader perspective on Kroger's fundamental profile, but they should not be interpreted as a direct assessment of its inventory accounting policy.

In particular, the financial-health and growth results reflect a broader set of quantitative evidence. The reported MOATEY data does not identify how much of any individual assessment is attributable specifically to the LIFO method or reserve.

The framework's current valuation explanation also identifies no sufficiently attractive estimated margin of safety and limited evidence of a lasting competitive advantage.

That does not imply Kroger has no operational strengths or predict that its share price must decline. It describes the present outcome under MOATEY's systematic assessment.

Readers who want to examine the framework's methodology and supporting validation research can review the MOATEY factsheet and documentation.

Five questions investors should ask about inventory accounting

The first question is which inventory method the company uses. Investors should determine whether the business reports inventory using FIFO, LIFO, weighted average cost or another permitted approach, and whether different categories of inventory use different methods.

Second, examine the size and direction of any LIFO reserve. A substantial reserve can indicate that the recognized inventory balance differs significantly from the company's inventory value before its LIFO adjustment.

Third, identify the effect on reported earnings. The period's LIFO charge or credit can help investors separate inventory accounting changes from the wider development of operating profitability.

Fourth, investigate the possibility of inventory liquidation. Significant reductions in inventory levels can sometimes cause older cost layers to influence reported earnings, producing an accounting benefit that may not persist.

Finally, compare businesses using consistent assumptions. A higher margin or larger inventory carrying value does not necessarily indicate superior economics when the businesses use different cost methods.

These questions should complement, rather than replace, the analysis of sales growth, inventory turnover, supplier costs, working capital and returns on invested capital.

The purpose is to understand what the reported numbers represent before deciding what they imply about business quality.

Kroger illustrates why accounting methods should be understood alongside the fundamentals. With a free MOATEY account, investors can unlock up to 10 companies across the platform, review their current assessments, add businesses to a watchlist or portfolio, and follow important Events such as rating, classification and underlying evidence changes. Explore Kroger on MOATEY.

The accounting method is not the underlying business

Kroger's $2.55 billion LIFO reserve demonstrates how substantially inventory cost assumptions can influence reported asset values.

Its $157 million fiscal 2025 LIFO charge also shows that the accounting method can affect reported operating profitability, even though it does not change the merchandise sold to customers.

Those effects deserve attention, especially when comparing companies across accounting frameworks or interpreting year-over-year changes in margins.

But the accounting adjustments do not replace an assessment of the business itself.

A retailer ultimately creates value by serving customers profitably, managing inventory efficiently, generating sustainable cash flows and earning attractive returns on the capital required to operate.

Inventory accounting determines how some of those results are recognized. It does not create the underlying economic performance.

For long-term investors, the useful approach is to understand both perspectives. First identify how the financial statements measure inventory costs. Then examine whether the business is genuinely becoming more efficient, profitable and resilient.

A reported margin is a starting point. Understanding the accounting behind it helps investors determine what the number actually says about the company.